College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

Facts make a case for gay adoption, no matter what opponents will say

a>

Published: Tuesday, October 22, 2002

Updated: Saturday, October 10, 2009

"Children raised by gay parents are more likely to be molested."

"Children need both a mother and father figure."

"Gay parents make gay kids."

These are just a few morsels of ignorance I thought I'd share with you today. There really is nothing quite like a person who has so much conviction about a topic he or she knows virtually nothing about. It is a sad and pathetic display of hatred and intolerance.

Homosexual couples can't be parents? Give me three good reasons why you think a gay couple can't raise a child properly, and I will give you eight better reasons that will prove you wrong.

In an earlier era, the attacks were leveled against single men and women seeking to adopt. And no doubt before that, the small-minded individuals of our fine country decided it was not right for black men and women to adopt white children or Jewish men and women to adopt Christian children and so on.

"Don't confuse me with the facts," as the adage goes.

The far right has blocked gay adoption in a number of states, including several in the South, such as Florida, Arkansas and Mississippi. This is all in the name of protecting children.

This is all in spite of the fact that over the past two decades, heterosexual and homosexual households have been found comparable in terms of children's relationship with their peers, children's self esteem, quality of parent-child relationships and the psychological well-being of both parents and children.

All this exists in spite of the fact that the American Psychological Association, the National Council for Adoptable Children and the Child Welfare League of America, experts on what's best for kids, have each publicly declared that restrictions on gay adoption is not only bad policy, but it's harmful toward children.

Conservatives want children adopted by "normal" families, which, according to them, includes a mother, father, dog and white picket fence (preferably white ... shhh).

But what Trent Lott and Jesse Helms and their ilk don't want to acknowledge is that less than one in every four households has the traditional husband, wife and child.

They also would like to overlook problems like child abuse, neglect, divorce and other problems that are just as likely to affect traditional households as any other.

It's easier to believe out-of-date stereotypes and to try to remember the good ol' days of the 1950s and before when it was tolerated -- and in some places encouraged -- to make blacks, Hispanics, Asians, Jews and gays the outcasts of society.

Open your eyes: being heterosexual and married does not make you an automatic candidate for "Parent of the Year."

There are 568,000 children in foster care in the U.S. -- only 46,000 will be adopted this year. In 1999, the number of kids entering foster care was triple that of kids adopted out of foster care.

Each year, 25,000 foster kids leave the system, having turned 18 years old and never having had parents. Is this a healthy way to raise children?

Among gay couples, 49% want to adopt, and many are willing to take on "less desirable" children -- ones with physical or mental disabilities or with HIV. They just want a child to love.

The irony is that in most states, gay couples can be foster parents. Nationally, 64% of adoptive parents were the foster parents that the children already knew, trusted and maybe loved.

But that doesn't matter to those wonderful child advocates known as the far right. If the loving foster parents happen to be gay in certain states, it's "tough luck, kid, and off you go." Again I ask, is this a healthy way to raise children?

The only proven difference between children from heterosexual households and children from gay households is just that -- a difference, and one that might be a positive for many children.

Kids raised by gay parents are less confined by traditional gender roles. Consider this: 52 percent of girls raised in gay households wanted to be career-oriented while a mere 21 percent of girls raised by straight moms had these goals.

Those are the facts, people.

If the far-right minded ever respected those facts, maybe a few things would change -- like more children would be loved by two parents.

Simply put, the same rules that would be used to determine if a straight couple is good for adoption should be used for gay couples.

What is the length and strength of the relationship? Is the couple financially prepared to care for a child?

Can the couple provide a safe and healthy environment? Is there any criminal history? Do the prospective parents have careers that will allow them to be home most nights with their child?

If the answers all come back positive, then sexual orientation shouldn't matter.

And if the answers all come back positive, but sexual orientation does matter, as it does in far too many states, then the question is not about sexual orientation; it's about discrimination.

If all men (and women!) are created equal, let's not allow stereotypes to completely desecrate our Constitution.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

17 comments

Anonymous
Wed May 12 2010 11:39
I strongly agree with you all just because the parens are gay doesnt mean the childer will be. Personally i feel like this topic is petty for states to deny childer the right to a loveing careing family because of the sexual orintation of the adopties. Its not fair to anyone the kids or the homosexuals lookin to adopt.
Brian Rhinehart
Sat May 8 2010 15:36
I would also like to make comments to all individuals arguing that homosexuality is a choice rather than something we are genetically born with. I disagree completely. If we were to choose to live this way we would also be choosing to be discriminated. We would be choosing for you to make religious slurs and jokes towards us. We would be choosing to be killed rather than being forced to live a certain way than be happy in our own shoes. It's not a choice it's genetics. It's no different than individuals believing a book which is black and white filled with mysteries and the idea that "truly believing in God" is the only way. If you were to read the Bible correctly and were a "follower of the Lord" you would also know that God says not to judge. So don't. Believe what you may, but don't think that you are in the "right of the Lord" to point fingers when there are thousands pointing right back to you.

Thank you.

-Brian

Brian Rhinehart
Sat May 8 2010 15:28
I'm currently writing a speech about the adoption of children by homosexuals (myself being a male homosexual). This truly helped my speech!

Greatly appreciated!

-Brian

antigay
Wed Apr 14 2010 00:56
ALL GAYs GO TO HELL AND YOU ALL HAVE MENTAL DISABILTYS. MAY GOD HAVE MERCY ON YOUR SOULS
Anonymous
Thu Apr 8 2010 10:41
First things first. I have to say that reading these comments, it is hard to believe that this a college paper and that the people reading it are in college. The writing, grammar, spelling errors, and punctuation errors look like some middle school mess.
Whoever wrote this article obviously has a huge chip on their shoulder and is just as incorrect in their sterotypes and hate speech as the stereotypes and hate speech they are contesting. I thought you aspiring journalists would do better research.
Anonymous
Sun Mar 21 2010 21:41
They say they want to protect the child. They don't know what the child feels. They just want to be in a home with loving parents. homosexual or not. And when they say that the child will become gay that's not true. They just become more comfortable with homosexuals.
Anonymous
Thu Mar 11 2010 18:39
You DO choose to be gay. You were not born that way!
Leviticus 20:13 "'If a man lies with a man as one lies with a woman, both of them have done what is detestable. They must be put to death; their blood will be on their own heads.

Why would Gpd create you to be gay if this is in His word?! HE wouldn't. Being homosexual is a choice you make for yourself. You are an abomination to Him, end of story.

Gay adoption should be legal!!!
Thu Mar 4 2010 23:34
All I just want to say is that we are all created EQUAL. Not meaning that strait people are more equal than gay and lesbians, but that all of us are equal as one and that orientation should not matter when it comes to adopting if they qualify having a wilingness to raise a child with love and care (and financial stuff), and last but not least a providing home.
Michael Morgan
Fri Feb 26 2010 23:12
communist PC tripe.
chrissy sickler
Tue Feb 16 2010 14:12
nothings wrong with gay people adopting i mean im bisexual... but i like girls more and am a chick.. i soon wanna adopt too. poeple always tell me ( guys say this ) "oh its alright if your lesbian, but gay guys THATS NASTY"... and thats wrong. if you think its okay for lesbians its okay for gay guys also. i mean, people now days are cruel and rude. i think you should be able to like who you want and not get made fun of.... people treat gay people, like were not even human! its not right, we dont do or say anything wrong about them being straight. i think everyone should like everyone for who they are.

thats all i have to say. thanks.

raisedbygays
Tue Feb 16 2010 08:15
You are so stupid Jamie. I don't know what kind of society you are talking about. You said, "every child deserves to grow up an dlive a normal life with a mother and a father". What century are you living? Better wake up man. Times have changed that already. That normal thing you are talking about is called stereo-type nowaday. If you truly care about the welfare of those children in an orphanage, then you shouldn't put walls on who should adopt them. You said gay adoption is very wrong? What is right to you? A straight couple who leaves their child in an orphanage? Why do you think orphanage are getting populated? Whose children are those anyway? Surely they're not from gay couple. Think about. And let me know what society you are talking about. Fool!
Josh
Tue Dec 15 2009 19:21
I know that homosexuals might be better parents than hetrosexulas but all you people are speaking on of the adults and not the children how do you think a four year child with 2 fathers would feel. He or She doesnt have a say in this becasuse they dont know what homosexuals are or what their social life might be like . Their just children they dont know what half this stuff means and im for gay marriage becasue all their affecting is themselves but with adoption there adopting the kids
Ashley
Wed Dec 2 2009 19:50
I am first of all not gay or lesbian... but I have to ask you Jamie.... what is a normal family? These days there is not one normal family. I agree with gay adoption because there are straight parents who can not raise thier children, so I do not believe that sexual orientation makes you a better/worse parent. I believe there are too many children that need good homes to be so picky about where they should go in this sense. If the homosexual couple is responsible, financially and mentally prepared for a child, and can raise a child successfully, then I believe that they should have the chance to do so. I am not saying I agree with being gay because it's not my place to judge someone for that, but gay people are still people with feelings and hopes and dreams just like everyone else and they deserve a chance at happiness as well! I totally agree with you Jason, because a child needs a good home no matter what the parents sexual orientation is!
Jason Crawford
Sat Nov 28 2009 17:20
You're an idiot Jamie! I am gay and didn't choose it. I was born this way and have known it for a very long time. At the age of 18 I didn't wake up one morning and decide to be gay the rest of my life! As time goes on, we'll have less people that think the way you do. Therefore, it will be easier to have an accepting cohesive society where children can be adopted and it won't matter if the adoptive parents are straight or gay. Children need a loving home where they can be provided for with an education, a warm dinner, and a fantastic family. My partner and I are starting to investigate the process of adoption. I work in the legal field and he is in his last year of law school. We will make great parents to a child. Why should a child be denied a loving family and forced to live in a orphanage? We just spent Thanksgiving with my family and extended family. They are all excited about us potentially adopting and can't wait to welcome a new family member. However, there are cruel people like you, Jamie, that would rather see a child in an orphanage than raised in a loving family. Shame on you!
Jamie Howard
Mon Nov 23 2009 21:52
Gay adoption is very wrong, and not right. I'm not saying that gay couples couldn't raise a child. But that every child deserves to grow up and live a normal life with a mother and a father. No matter what any body says that's the truth about it. People also may say that gays are willing to adopt kids with dissabilties and that nobody else will take them in, but that's not true either. There are many other married "Husband", and "wife" couples willing to adopt these children to. So i think gay couples need to think about the kids before they adopt them. Its not right. In many ways. If its not possible to produce a kid between a couple of the same sex then maybe they should realize its not right, and if they chose to be gay then they should have to deal with not having a child because it's not proper or right. Think about the kids once and with today's society!
Brittany
Wed Nov 11 2009 22:46
Thank You Kim! I am a lesbian that soon in the future will want to adopt and there are so many people that, even in this day in time, remain to discriminate. So, i just wanted to say thank you to you and everyone else with a brain that can understand that me and everyother homosexual are humans just as anyone else and we deserve that same repect and rights as anyother americans!
Alex Boyer
Wed Nov 11 2009 12:53
vedy goot






log out